In the end, it was a philosophical battle that tested who is best responsible for the future of retirement savings in Canada: only 18.6% of respondants to Knowledge Bureau’s July poll question answered yes when asked, “In your opinion, is the enhanced CPP a better retirement savings plan than putting the equivalent amount of premiums into a TFSA?” The remaining 81.4% voted no—in favor of the tax-paid contributions to a tax-exempt savings vehicle over mandatory, partially deductible contributions to a taxable fund.